West Wing alum Timothy Busfield has been painted as an evil predator, but his legal team has produced evidence that tells a dramatically different story.
In a court filing, his lawyers presented police audio and an independent investigation that they claim clears the actor of abusing twin underage boys.
Busfield, 68, faces two counts of criminal sexual contact of a minor and one count of child abuse in New Mexico for acts that allegedly occurred on the set of The Cleaning Lady. He was a director on the series.
But his defense team argues the police audio includes an “unequivocal denial” by both boys that Busfield touched them inappropriately.
The boys, 11-year-old child actors, were interviewed by police in November 2024.
Bernalillo County/MEGA
In the audio, an officer gently asks, “You know no one can touch your private areas?” The twins respond saying, “Yes,” according to the audio obtained by TMZ.
The officer then asks if Busfield ever touches their private parts, which both the boys deny. “But he didn’t touch that part,” one child says in one clip.
“No, he’s never touched me,” the other boy adds in a separate audio recording.
But prosecutors, according to Busfield’s defense, said the audio showed the boys didn’t “disclose” abuse.
Getty Images
Additional papers filed by Busfield include the independent investigation, conducted by a workplace investigator hired by Warner Bros. Studios after an anonymous complaint was made. In the report, multiple cast and crew members on the TV series addressed claims that Busfield “isolated,” “groomed” and “inappropriately touched” the show’s twin child actors.
“Every witness was ‘shocked’ by the allegations that Mr. Busfield engaged in inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature or otherwise, especially toward minor children,” said workplace investigator Christina McGovern.
Several witnesses said it would be highly unlikely for Busfield to have been alone with the boys, and no one reported witnessing any instances of the Emmy winner acting inappropriately, according to the report.
McGovern wrote: “Witnesses described Mr. Busfield as ‘caring’ and ‘patient’ with all actors on set, including the minor actors” — and concluded the evidence did not support the complaints against him.
Busfield was released on the condition he has no unsupervised contact with minors until his trial.