Crime

Youth Pastor Accused of Pushing Wife Off Cliff Amid Affair Collected $600K From Her Insurance Policy

Tyler McCarthy

Updated

on

Resoluna/YouTube; 8 News Now Las Vegas/Youtube

A crime story involving a man who allegedly murdered his wife by pushing her off of a cliff has resurfaced two decades later — and just months after his death.

According to People, on August 22, 2006, David Vander Meer looked visibly injured as he trekked down Angels Landing in Utah’s Zion National Park. When he encountered other hikers, he told them a man’s wife had fallen off a cliff — but did not allude to the fact that it was his own wife, Bernadette Vander Meer.

David told multiple investigators the same story: He and Bernadette left their hotel at 3:30 a.m., drove to a parking lot, took bikes to a trail and made the hike up to the summit of Angel’s Landing by 6:10 a.m. He explained they planned to take photos at the tourist hotspot but it was not yet time for sunrise, so they agreed to take her photo in silhouette. He told everyone that he turned to move their backpacks out of frame, heard a scream and when he looked back, his wife was gone.

People reports that, because his story never changed, her death was ruled accidental. However, it was reclassified as a murder two decades later, after it came to light that he was having an affair with an underage high school girl at the time.

The Washington County Attorney’s Office learned David’s affair with a girl he met working as a youth pastor when she was 14 went on for years, after she became his mistress when she was 16. Two days before the alleged killing, she told him she wanted to end their relationship.

8 News Now Las Vegas/Youtube

However, in a separate report, People notes that the pair got married two years after Bernadette’s death. Following their 2026 divorce, David’s second wife informed the police about their past affair.

In June of 2026, David was arrested in Nevada and indicted on a charge of murder.

Additionally, he also faced an indictment for insurance fraud for collecting a $600,000 payout for Bernadette’s life insurance policy.

A few days later, he died of self-inflicted injuries while awaiting extradition to Utah. In a note left behind prior to his death, David maintained his innocence.

Trending News

REAL ESTATE1 week ago

JD Vance’s Temporary Florida Home Owned by President Trump Hits Rental Market for $110K a Month

Donald Trump and Nicki Minaj Donald Trump and Nicki Minaj
Politics2 weeks ago

President Trump Doesn’t Know Nicki Minaj Isn’t a US Citizen Amid New Press Secretary Speculation

News2 weeks ago

Young Pilot’s Harrowing Last Words Revealed Before Florida Plane Crash That Killed All on Board

Celebrity News1 week ago

Kid Rock Hit With Backlash After Positing Hunting Photo With Dead Elk: ‘How Sick Is This’

Exclusive1 week ago

Meghan Markle’s Dad Thomas Once Bragged About ‘Incredible’ Things He Paid Women to Do to Him Prior to Arrest

Crime2 weeks ago

Mother Receives 7 Consecutive Life Sentences for Allowing Husband to Impregnate Her Daughter

RELATIONSHIPS6 days ago

Ainsley Earhardt Admits New Husband Sean Hannity ‘Won’t Let’ Her Get the Cosmetic Procedure She Wants

Stephen Baldwin, Chynna Phillips, Bijou Phillips, Mackenzie Phillips, Billy Baldwin Stephen Baldwin, Chynna Phillips, Bijou Phillips, Mackenzie Phillips, Billy Baldwin
Celebrity2 weeks ago

Mackenzie, Chynna and Bijou Phillips Enjoy Mini-Reunion at Event Years After Family Turmoil

Politics7 days ago

Franklin Graham Warns ‘Religion Can’t Save You’ After President Donald Trump’s ‘60 Minutes’ Interview

Don Jr. and Russell Brand Don Jr. and Russell Brand
Legal News4 days ago

Donald Trump Jr. Defends Russell Brand Following Prison Sentencing: ‘No One Had a Problem With It’

Politics2 weeks ago

Elderly New Hampshire Man Slapped Turning Point Activist During Polling Station Showdown

Crime2 weeks ago

Suspiciously Large Costco Order From School Cook Leads to Discovery of $300K Embezzlement Schemes