What began as ghostly images of corroded barrels surrounded by pale rings in the seafloor sediment has now been traced to a long-hidden source: caustic alkaline waste that has lingered beneath the ocean off Los Angeles for more than half a century.
The “halo barrels” first seen in viral images in 2020 were initially suspected to be caused by the toxic pesticide DDT, but a new study from University of California San Diegos Scripps Institution of Oceanography, suggests the barrels contained alkaline waste that leaked out and transformed parts of the seafloor into extreme environments, reminiscent of hydrothermal vents.
The findings, published in PNAS Nexus, suggest that the waste not only created the white halos visible from remotely operated submersibles but has also persisted for decades, impacting microbial life in the deep.
“One of the main waste streams from DDT production was acid and they didnt put that into barrels,” said Johanna Gutleben, a Scripps postdoctoral scholar and the studys first author. “It makes you wonder: What was worse than DDT acid waste to deserve being put into barrels?”
Paul Jensen, emeritus marine microbiologist at Scripps and senior author of the study, admitted he was surprised by the findings. He said he would have expected alkaline waste to quickly dissipate in seawater, but instead it has remained in place for decades, suggesting the waste “can now join the ranks of DDT as a persistent pollutant with long-term environmental impacts.”
The study grew out of a 2021 expedition aboard the Schmidt Ocean Institutes Research Vessel Falkor, where sediment samples were taken near barrels with halos. Researchers discovered the sediment was highly alkaline, with a pH around 12, and that microbial life was limited to extremophiles adapted to such harsh conditions. Analysis of hardened crust from the seafloor revealed brucite, a mineral that forms when alkaline waste reacts with seawater, cementing the sediment and leaving behind halos of white calcium carbonate dust.
“DDT was not the only thing that was dumped in this part of the ocean and we have only a very fragmented idea of what else was dumped there,” Gutleben said. “We only find what we are looking for and up to this point we have mostly been looking for DDT. Nobody was thinking about alkaline waste before this and we may have to start looking for other things as well.”
From the 1930s to the early 1970s, Southern Californias deep-water dump sites received not only DDT waste but also oil refinery byproducts, chemical refuse, military explosives and even radioactive material. Recent surveys have identified thousands of objects, including military munitions, but the number of barrels on the seafloor remains unknown. Roughly a third of those visually observed show halos, suggesting widespread alkaline contamination.
“This adds to our understanding of the consequences of the dumping of these barrels,” said Jensen. “Its shocking that 50-plus years later youre still seeing these effects. We cant quantify the environmental impact without knowing how many of these barrels with white halos are out there, but its clearly having a localized impact on microbes.”
Co-author Lisa Levin, emeritus biological oceanographer at Scripps, previously found that small animal biodiversity around halo barrels was reduced, further underscoring the ecological toll. The researchers now suggest that using halos as markers could help rapidly assess the spread of alkaline waste contamination.
Jensen and Gutleben are also experimenting with DDT-contaminated sediments to see if microbes might be capable of breaking down the pesticide, which was largely pumped directly into the ocean before its U.S. ban in 1972. But Jensen cautioned that physical removal of sediments is likely too dangerous.
“The highest concentrations of DDT are buried around 4 or 5 centimeters below the surface — so its kind of contained,” he said. “If you tried to suction that up you would create a huge sediment plume and stir that contamination into the water column.”