A new genetic study from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and Morfeld Research & Conservation has found that giraffes in U.S. zoos and private collections are so heavily hybridized across species that they no longer represent viable conservation backups for their wild counterparts.
“Captive breeding programs in zoos would be better off restarting with fresh stocks from the wild, if they want to maintain assurance stocks for the purposes of conservation,” said Alfred Roca, senior author of the study published in the Journal of Heredity and professor in the Department of Animal Sciences at Illinois.
With roughly 97,500 wild giraffes remaining across 21 African countries, the species is listed as vulnerable on the IUCN Red List, with several populations considered critically endangered. Once thought to comprise nine subspecies of a single species, recent genetic research has revealed four distinct species that rarely interbreed in the wild — a discovery that has major implications for how giraffes should be managed in captivity.
As genetic “insurance” for wild populations, captive animals should mirror those species distinctions, but when Rocas team analyzed DNA from 52 giraffes housed in American zoos and private ranches, they found extensive interbreeding between species.
“We compared the DNA sequences of giraffes from North American collections to 63 wild individuals across all four species and were able to see how strongly their genetics aligned with different species in the wild,” said Wesley Au, first author of the study and doctoral researcher in informatics at Illinois. “Only eight giraffes got close to representing a single species — reaching about a 90% match — but the rest were a mix of two and sometimes three species.”
According to Chris Fields, co-author and director of the HPCBio core at the Roy J. Carver Biotechnology Center, the study demonstrates how genomic comparisons can expose the hidden complexities of captive populations.
“This study demonstrates how to perform conservation studies through genomics, by comparing genome data from the giraffes to reference genomes from wild species,” Fields said.
The researchers traced some of the hybridization to historical management policies. In 2004, the Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA) consolidated its giraffe breeding program into a single “generic” unit, rather than maintaining separate programs for each subspecies. That decision, Roca noted, came before the current genetic distinctions were fully recognized.
“The AZA decision acknowledged that hybridization was already extensive within its giraffe population,” he said. “Additionally, I’m not sure it was obvious in 2004 that the animals were from such disparate genetic stocks. Those studies came later, so it’s not surprising.”
Kari Morfeld, reproductive physiologist and owner of Morfeld Research & Conservation, said breeding decisions often prioritize temperament over genetics.
“A lot of times, decisions to breed animals are based on, She’s a nice female, he’s a nice male. Let’s put them together for breeding. The genetics arent usually considered in making breeding decisions for giraffes, but they should be,” Morfeld said. “We have a responsibility to consider genetics, not only demeanor or physical characteristics, to do better for giraffe conservation.”
The team recommends gradually phasing out hybridized individuals from conservation breeding programs while still recognizing their value as educational ambassadors. Some could serve as surrogates for implanted embryos derived from genetically pure wild populations, a strategy that could strengthen future conservation efforts without physically relocating adult animals.
“Physically moving these huge animals between continents would be difficult,” Morfeld said. “So, a better way, in my opinion, is to develop reproductive technologies where you can move semen or embryos and proceed with artificial insemination, IVF, and embryo transfer. We do this all the time in livestock and other species. There’s no reason this can’t be applied to giraffes.”
Ultimately, the researchers said that protecting wild populations in Africa must remain the priority.
“There are a lot of things to consider beyond moving genetics,” Morfeld said. “It really comes down to establishing trusting relationships with African governments, conservation organizations, and scientists. It’s one thing to conduct an artificial insemination, but you really have to ask the question of how all stakeholders will benefit.”
The study highlights a growing challenge for conservation science: ensuring that animals bred in captivity remain true genetic representatives of their wild relatives — not just symbols of them.