Shark meat sold in American supermarkets, seafood markets, and online retailers is not always what it seems — and in many cases, it comes from species that are critically endangered.
Researchers at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill tested 29 shark meat products sold through grocery stores, seafood markets, and online vendors across the U.S., then used DNA barcoding to determine their species. The results, published in Frontiers in Marine Science, showed that 93% were sold under vague labels and included meat from 11 different shark species.
Some of the products contained great hammerheads and scalloped hammerheads, both listed as critically endangered by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). Despite their rarity, meat from these sharks was available to U.S. consumers for as little as $2.99 per pound.
“Mislabeling and ambiguous labeling remove consumers ability to choose what they are putting in their bodies,” said Savannah Ryburn, Ph.D., first author of the study and co-instructor of the seafood forensics class that conducted the research. “For example, two species in our study, scalloped hammerhead and great hammerhead, were ambiguously labeled as shark, even though they are strongly advised against consumption due to their very high mercury levels. Without accurate and precise labeling, consumers cannot avoid purchasing these products.”
Of the 29 products examined, 27 were labeled simply as “shark” without a species designation, or “mako shark.” Even one of the two samples that included a species name turned out to be incorrectly identified.
“The United States should require seafood distributors to provide species-specific names for the products being sold,” said John Bruno, Ph.D., distinguished professor and co-instructor of the seafood forensics class.
More than simply an ecological problem, mislabeling presents health risks. Shark meat is known to contain elevated levels of mercury, posing risks especially for children and pregnant people.
“Sharks such as great and scalloped hammerheads are the oceans equivalent of lions, and we were shocked by how cheaply the meat of these rare, long-lived apex predators was sold,” Ryburn said. “Some samples were only $2.99 per pound.”
The study adds to a growing body of research using DNA barcoding to track how shark products are labeled in the U.S. The researchers say their work shows the need for stricter rules to protect both public health and threatened shark populations.