Children are famous for their short attention spans and tendency to “over explore” instead of sticking to a task. Now, scientists at The Ohio State University say theyve pinpointed why — and even managed to make adults behave the same way.
According to a new study in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, the reason children are so easily distracted is that their working memory isnt yet developed enough to hold goals in mind and focus their attention. Without that control, according to Ohio State psychology professor and study co-author Vladimir Sloutsky, attention has no single target and becomes “diffused.”
To test their theory, Sloutsky and lead author Qianqian Wan, former Ohio State doctoral student in psychology and now a postdoctoral researcher at the University of California-Davis, overloaded adults working memory to mimic a childs.
“We made it difficult for adults to focus by filling their working memory with things that werent relevant to what they were trying to accomplish. And when we did that, adults began to over explore and scatter their attention much like children do,” Sloutsky said.
“Importantly, like in children, this scattered attention was observed, despite high levels of task accuracy,” Wan said.
The researchers recruited 40 children 5-year-olds and 71 adults for a computerized “candy-collecting” game. Players chose between four alien creatures, each offering a different number of virtual candies. To win, they had to learn which creature delivered the most candy.
Some adults were also given an extra task designed to tax their working memory: tracking a stream of numbers on the screen and calling out when two odd numbers appeared consecutively.
At the end of the experiment, both adults and children correctly identified which alien offered the highest reward — proving they learned the rules. But their behavior told a different story.
“As we expected from previous research, the children were generally slower to start selecting the most rewarding creature and switched creatures much more often than the adults who werent asked to do an additional task,” said Wan. “But the adults who were under the working memory load behaved much like the children, not settling on the most rewarding creature. It is compelling evidence that an undeveloped working memory is behind childrens tendency to distribute their attention.”
The findings show that when working memory is overloaded, even adults lose the ability to focus narrowly. The authors say the study suggests that working memory is involved in the active maintenance and updating of mental “attentional maps.”
“These maps may guide attention to what is deemed important, allow selective information sampling and more efficient task performance,” Wan said. “But if you dont have sufficient working memory resources, these maps become harder to form and maintain. The result is that you have to broaden your attention to compensate for uncertainty.”
Rather than seeing childrens distractibility as a flaw, Sloutsky said, it may reflect an adaptive feature of developing minds. Over-exploring their surroundings could actually help children learn more flexibly than adults, and even notice things that adults miss.
“These findings could inform teaching strategies that work with, rather than against, young childrens natural learning tendencies,” Wan said.