A frustrated judge declared a mistrial in a case about a man accused of killing and assaulting a 5-year-old after jurors allegedly broke several rules and brought outside information they weren’t supposed to have into the deliberations.
On Tuesday, October 13, 12 jurors began deciding the fate of David Prevatte, who pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and statutory sexual offense for allegedly harming his niece, according to an October 15 report on CourtTV. The outlet reports that deliberations abruptly stopped Thursday morning when the bailiff got a complaint that Juror No. 3 was making comments to the others about the defendant not being a member of the Ku Klux Klan, which was never mentioned during the trial.
Judge Ricardo Jensen called each juror back one-by-one and questioned them about the statements. Multiple other jurors corroborated the account brought to the bailiff’s attention and even noted that Juror No. 3 said: “I know things about this [case], but I can’t say.”
Juror No. 3 allegedly also told other jurors the defendant couldn’t be racist because he had a Black girlfriend with whom he shares a child, another alleged fact not brought up at trial, per the outlet. At this point, prosecutors believed Juror No. 3 was not forthright with her initial screen questionnaire and asked for her to be removed.
YouTube/Court TV
As Juror No. 3 was being relieved, she brought other information about jurors having outside information they were sharing in deliberations. Juror No. 4 and 2 were accused of discussing the defendant’s rap sheet, including other crimes for which he was not on trial.
“At the outset of today, we had a report from one of the jurors that seems to have opened Pandora’s box,” Jensen said, noting that, when all the complaints were heard, there were roughly seven out of 12 jurors who had grounds for dismissal — more than there were alternates to take over.
After declaring a mistrial and dismissing the jury, the judge asked Jurors No. 2 and 4 to stay behind and, according to CourtTV, scolded them.
“The reason for the mistrial is based on misconduct by you,” Jensen said. “This is not a discussion, but an admonition.”
YouTube/Court TV
Speaking to WWAY TV3 after the mistrial was declared and she was dismissed, Juror No. 3, whose comment kickstarted the mistrial, said she “just tried to speak my mind and just stand up for what I believe in.”
She also accused other jurors of making threats against her for being adamant about her position on the matter.
“I was one of two who felt very strongly in one way. And everybody else was very adamant,” she said. “There were comments made. There were threats made to my, you know, about my children.”
Juror No. 3 also told the outlet that she denied saying the things she was accused of saying, noting how hard she tried to remain unbiased.
Prevatte is scheduled to appear in court on November 13 for a hearing to discuss his second trial.