Nicolás Lira Turpaud (ALMA Observatory) & adapted from Cox et al. 2025
An astronomical anomaly — an Einstein Cross with too many points — led astrophysicists to find what they say is a “hidden halo of dark matter.”
When theoretical astrophysicist Charles Keeton was shown an unusual telescope image by colleague Andrew Baker, he immediately knew something was off.
“Have you ever seen an Einstein Cross with an image in the middle?” Baker asked.
“I said, well, thats not supposed to happen,” recalled Keeton, Vice Provost for Experiential Learning at Rutgers University-New Brunswick. “You cant get a fifth image in the center unless something unusual is going on with the mass thats bending the light.”
An Einstein Cross occurs when the gravity of nearer galaxies bends light from a much more distant galaxy into four distinct images. The fifth image spotted in the center of this Einstein Cross pointed to something more: a massive, unseen ring of dark matter. That invisible structure proved to be the key to understanding the anomaly. The international research teams findings are now published in The Astrophysical Journal.
Dark matter, which makes up most of the matter in the universe, cannot be observed directly. Its presence is revealed only through its effects.
“We only know its there because of how it affects the things we can see, like the way it bends light from distant galaxies,” said Baker, Distinguished Professor in the Department of Physics and Astronomy at Rutgers. “This discovery gives us a rare chance to study that invisible structure in detail.”
Pierre Cox, a French astronomer and Research Director at the French National Centre for Scientific Research, initially spotted the unusual image while working with data from the Northern Extended Millimeter Array (NOEMA) in the French Alps.
“We were like, What the heck?” Cox said. “It looked like a cross, and there was this image in the center. I knew I had never seen that before.”
The team was studying HerS-3, a dusty, faraway galaxy. Observations with NOEMA and Chiles Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) showed that its light split into five images instead of four. At first, researchers thought it might be a data glitch. But the central image persisted.
“We tried to get rid of it,” Cox said. “We thought it was a problem with the instrument. But it was real.”
To unravel the mystery, Keeton and Rutgers graduate student Lana Eid constructed detailed gravitational lensing models. Their work showed that the visible galaxies alone couldnt explain the image pattern. A massive dark matter halo had to be included.
“We tried every reasonable configuration using just the visible galaxies, and none of them worked,” said Keeton, also a professor in Rutgers Department of Physics and Astronomy. “The only way to make the math and the physics line up was to add a dark matter halo. Thats the power of modeling. It helps reveal what you cant see.”
The unusual lensing effect, apart from aiding the study of dark matter, also magnifies the background galaxy, offering astronomers a more detailed view of its structure.
“This system is like a natural laboratory,” Cox said. “We can study both the distant galaxy and the invisible matter thats bending its light.”
Baker noted that global teamwork and federal science funding made the breakthrough possible.
“ALMA in Chile and the Very Large Array (VLA) in New Mexico are supported by the National Science Foundation, and the Hubble Space Telescope is supported by NASA; all played vital roles in this work,” he said. “We hope they will continue to enable such discoveries well into the future.”
The team has predicted that followup observations could show features such as outflowing gas.
“This is a falsifiable prediction,” Keeton said. “If we look and dont see it, well have to go back to the drawing board. Thats how science works.”