A Georgia man is accused of creating a fake female persona that became so convincing, one victim reportedly believed he was engaged to her.
Law&Crime reported on Sunday, September 6, that authorities said Caleb Mills was behind the online persona known as “Hailey Morello” — a supposed female sheriff’s deputy whom one victim believed he was engaged to without ever meeting in person.
Mills, 25, allegedly relied on photographs taken from women’s social media accounts, several phone numbers, artificial intelligence, and voice-changing technology to maintain the identity.
In an official press release posted on Facebook on September 3, the Athens-Clarke County Police Department said one victim gave money to the person he believed was Hailey and exchanged vehicles with Mills as part of the alleged scheme.
Police said the photos used for the identity belonged to a real sheriff’s deputy in Florida.
The victim’s relatives eventually became suspicious and tried to convince him he was being catfished.
May 23, 2026, Washington, District Of Columbia, USA: Armed secret police divert traffic on a blocked street near a crime scene not far from the White House in Washington, DC, USA on May 23, 2026. Police and security forces swarmed the area around the White House on the evening of May 23 after reports of shots fired. 23 May 2026 Pictured: May 23, 2026, Washington, District Of Columbia, USA: Police tape blocks off a crime scene on a sidewalk on 17th and Pennsylvania Ave near the White House in Washington, DC, USA on May 23, 2026. Police and security forces swarmed the area around the White House on the evening of May 23 after reports of shots fired. Photo credit: ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA TheMegaAgency.com sales@mega.global (Mega Agency TagID: MEGA1455116_014.jpg) [Photo via Mega Agency]
According to police, their concerns ultimately helped lead investigators to Mills.
“Mills allegedly used photos taken from women’s social media accounts to create fake identities and accounts … to establish online relationships with victims,” police said. “Detectives have identified additional victims across multiple states.”
According to Fox Carolina, investigators said Mills was arrested on multiple charges, including identity fraud involving fictitious identifying information, impersonating a public officer, giving a false name to law enforcement and two counts of making false statements in a government matter. Authorities also allege he identified himself to investigators as “Alex Morello” before his arrest.
According to the outlet, police said investigators have identified other potential victims in multiple states, and the investigation remains ongoing. Officials further allege that Mills continued carrying out fraudulent activity after bonding out following his arrest, and additional charges could be filed.