Lee Watt / AFF-USA.COM / MEGA; Spread Pictures / MEGA
Andrew Rannells says he turned down a date with Kevin Spacey, after the actor — who was not out at the time — allegedly asked him out after seeing him perform in Book of Mormon.
The Broadway star, 48, shared his story about the L.A. Confidential actor, 67, in a November 17 episode of The Downside with Gianmarco Soresi podcast. Rannells, Gianmarco Soresi, and cohost Russell Daniels were talking about Netflix introducing the binge model when Spacey’s name came up — as House of Cards was one of the streamer’s early original hits.
“I’ve never told this story before. He asked me on a date once. He sent me a letter to The Book of Mormon. Handwritten,” claimed the Girls alum, who starred in the show as Elder Price from 2011 to 2012, after originating the role.
“He had come to see the show and he came backstage and it was a really weird night,” he continued. “There were always a lot of really fun people there, but sometimes they would bring them up into our dressing rooms, but with no notice.”
“So after the show, we’re like getting changed. I’m not fully dressed. There’s a knock on my door and it was Goldie Hawn, Kevin Spacey and Joel Schumacher,” he added. “They were not together, but they all walked up together.”
Recalling being in his “underwear and sweaty” at the time, Rannells said the group was “all crammed” into his dressing room, with Spacey “sort of rubbing my neck a little bit as we were standing there.”
He said the late Schumacher, who directed Spacey in the legal drama A Time to Kill, then told him, “Stay away from that man. Stay away from that man.”
“And Kevin was like, ‘Ah, come on, come on!’ and about a week later I got a handwritten letter from him asking me on a date and I just never responded,” claimed Rannells, who added that while he kept the letter for a “long time,” he eventually “got rid of it” after it “got less funny.”
Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency
The two-time Oscar winner was hit with a wave of sexual misconduct allegations in 2017. In 2022, Rent alum Anthony Rapp sued him in civil court for assault, though he was cleared of wrongdoing, per NPR. Then, in 2023, Spacey faced assault charges in London, but was ultimately acquitted of all nine charges, according to the New York Post.
As the National Enquirer previously reported, he also settled with three men accusing him of assault before a planned civil trial earlier this year, via the BBC.
Spacey has denied all allegations against him.
Of the letter, Rannells said it was “very flattering about how talented I was and would I also like to come to dinner.” He said that it was written on letterhead from the Old Vic theater, adding, “because he was running the Old Vic at the time. Running it into the ground, is more like it!”
Spacey has not commented on Rannells’ claims.
The New Normal alum said it wasn’t unusual for “Hollywood type men” to express interest in him at the time, saying many of those who saw the show “thought I was younger than I was.”
“I was 32, I think they would see me from the audience and I was playing a 19-year-old and they would do the math — ‘He’s probably like 25, maybe 23’ — and then they would see me up close and be like, ‘I’m out,'” he told the podcast cohosts.
“I would get meetings, people would see the show and they would set up a meeting and they would show up and be like, ‘Oh, you’re like an adult, never mind,'” he quipped.