A Florida man is facing charges for allegedly sending a piece of mail covered in peanut butter to a woman he knew had a peanut allergy, authorities said.
The Plantation Police Department said that on Aug. 14, 2025, a local resident reported receiving a greeting card in the mail that had been contaminated with peanut butter. The victim reported she immediately recognized the substance because she has a severe peanut allergy, and immediately tried to clean her hands. Still, she said she experienced an allergic reaction that included hives, redness, itching and tingling in her arms.
Investigators were eventually able to trace the stamps to a kiosk where they were purchased by credit card, and identified 68-year-old Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. as the suspect.
Plantation Police Department
According to police, the victim was known to Cancellare, and he was allegedly aware of her allergy.
According to an arrest report obtained by the New York Post, the victim had been friends with Cancellare’s ex-wife, and the three knew each other for decades. The victim reportedly witnessed the final division of property in the couple’s contentious divorce, and Cancellare allegedly blamed the victim for the failure of the marriage.
Cancellare was arrested on Nov. 13 and charged with aggravated battery and culpable negligence.